Choosing the right mascara can make all the difference in your makeup routine. Two popular options—Maneater Mascara and Too Faced Better Than Sex Mascara—have garnered a loyal following for their ability to deliver dramatic lashes. But which one truly reigns supreme? This article compares these two fan favorites based on formula, application, performance, and overall value to help you decide which mascara deserves a spot in your makeup bag.
Packaging and Wand Design
Maneater Mascara
Maneater comes in a sleek, modern tube with a dense brush featuring varying bristle lengths. This design aims to coat lashes evenly, providing volume and separation without clumping.
Too Faced Better Than Sex
Known for its iconic pink hourglass-shaped wand, Better Than Sex features thick bristles designed to grab every lash and amplify length and volume dramatically.
Formula and Pigmentation
Maneater Mascara
The formula is rich and creamy with intense black pigmentation. It includes conditioning ingredients to nourish lashes while providing bold color and volume.
Too Faced Better Than Sex
This mascara offers a deep, jet-black pigment with a thick, slightly wet formula that builds volume quickly but can be prone to clumping if over-applied.
Application Experience
Maneater Mascara
Application is smooth with a brush that separates lashes well, reducing clumps. Multiple coats build volume and length for a bold yet natural look.
Too Faced Better Than Sex
Better Than Sex provides instant drama with the first coat. The hourglass wand coats lashes thoroughly but may require a steady hand to avoid clumping and stickiness.
Wear and Longevity
Maneater Mascara
Maneater boasts smudge-proof, long-lasting wear that holds up well throughout the day and in humid conditions without flaking.
Too Faced Better Than Sex
Better Than Sex offers impressive staying power but may smudge slightly under intense heat or moisture. It can be more prone to flakes after extended wear.
Removal
Maneater Mascara
Removes with a good makeup remover, though its rich formula may require a bit more effort to fully cleanse.
Too Faced Better Than Sex
Can be stubborn to remove due to its thick formula but generally comes off with oil-based removers.
Price and Value
- Maneater Mascara: Mid-range pricing with great performance and added lash-conditioning benefits.
- Too Faced Better Than Sex: Slightly higher price point but considered a cult classic with proven results.
Final Verdict: Which Mascara Reigns Supreme?
- Choose Maneater Mascara if you want a nourishing, smudge-proof formula with buildable volume and a clean, clump-free finish. It’s excellent for everyday wear with bold results.
- Choose Too Faced Better Than Sex if you seek instant, dramatic volume and length with a signature wand but don’t mind spending extra time on careful application and removal.
Both mascaras excel in delivering bold lashes, but your choice depends on your priorities—whether it’s formula conditioning and longevity (Maneater) or iconic volume and immediate drama (Better Than Sex). Either way, these mascaras stand out as top contenders in the beauty world.