Whether you’re heading to a long event, sipping drinks, or just want your makeup to stay put all day, lip liner is essential for achieving defined, long-lasting lips. But when it comes to choosing between waterproof and regular lip liners, which one should you pick? Each type has its own strengths and weaknesses, depending on your needs, lifestyle, and lip care routine.
In this guide, we’ll compare waterproof and regular lip liners, explore their pros and cons, and recommend top picks in each category to help you find your perfect match.
What Is the Difference Between Waterproof and Regular Lip Liners?
- Waterproof lip liners are designed with long-wearing, smudge-resistant formulas that can withstand moisture, eating, drinking, and sweating.
- Regular lip liners, while still long-wearing in many cases, are not formulated to resist water or oils and may require more frequent touch-ups.
Pros and Cons of Waterproof Lip Liners
✅ Pros
- Long-Lasting Wear
Waterproof liners are ideal for all-day wear, resisting fading even through meals, drinks, or hot weather. - Smudge and Transfer Resistant
Once set, these liners typically won’t budge, making them great for events, weddings, or long shifts. - Excellent for Oily Skin or Humid Climates
They stay put even when your skin produces more oil or you’re exposed to moisture.
❌ Cons
- Harder to Remove
These liners often require an oil-based makeup remover, which can be inconvenient if you’re in a rush. - Can Be Drying
Some waterproof formulas can feel tight or dry, especially on already chapped lips. - Less Forgiving
Mistakes are harder to fix since the formula sets quickly and doesn’t blend as easily.
Pros and Cons of Regular Lip Liners
✅ Pros
- Creamier and More Comfortable
Regular liners are often formulated to glide smoothly and feel more hydrating. - Easier to Blend
Perfect for ombré lips, soft edges, or when you want to blend lip liner into lipstick seamlessly. - Better for Sensitive Lips
Less drying and often enriched with conditioning ingredients.
❌ Cons
- Not Transfer-Proof
May smudge or fade with eating, drinking, or sweating. - Frequent Reapplication Needed
Especially in long days or high-activity environments. - Not Ideal for Extreme Conditions
In hot, humid, or rainy weather, they may not hold up well.
Best Waterproof Lip Liners
1. Maybelline Color Sensational Shaping Lip Liner
Affordable and reliable, this liner is known for its waterproof formula and smooth glide.
2. Make Up For Ever Aqua Lip Waterproof Lip Liner
Loved by pros, it delivers intense color and incredible longevity without drying the lips.
3. Urban Decay 24/7 Glide-On Lip Pencil
Waterproof, creamy, and long-lasting—plus, it comes in a wide range of shades.
Best Regular Lip Liners
1. NYX Slim Lip Pencil
A cult favorite for its creamy texture and broad shade range at a budget-friendly price.
2. MAC Lip Pencil
An industry classic, offering blendable color with a professional finish.
3. Milani Color Statement Lipliner
Smooth, rich color payoff that pairs well with lipsticks and glosses alike.
Which One Should You Choose?
Choose Waterproof Lip Liner if:
- You need all-day or event-proof lip definition.
- You live in a humid climate or have oily skin.
- You want minimal touch-ups throughout the day.
Choose Regular Lip Liner if:
- You prioritize comfort and hydration.
- You enjoy blending or doing ombré lip looks.
- You don’t mind reapplying or want a softer finish.
Conclusion
Waterproof and regular lip liners both have their place in a well-rounded beauty routine. While waterproof options offer superior staying power and performance, regular liners provide comfort and versatility. Your best bet? Keep both in your makeup bag so you’re ready for any occasion—from low-maintenance days to all-night glam. With the right formula and shade, your lips will always be the star of your look.