When it comes to high-quality concealers, Hourglass Vanish Seamless Finish Concealer and Tarte Shape Tape are two of the most popular choices on the market. Both have amassed loyal followings thanks to their impressive coverage and flattering finishes. However, they cater to slightly different needs and preferences. If you’re torn between these two cult-favorites, this comparison will help you decide which concealer suits your skin type, coverage desires, and makeup routine best.
1. Coverage and Finish
Hourglass Vanish Concealer
- Coverage: Full coverage that’s buildable without looking cakey.
- Finish: Natural matte with a soft, skin-like appearance.
- Best for: Those seeking flawless coverage with a lightweight feel and a finish that doesn’t look flat or dry.
Tarte Shape Tape Concealer
- Coverage: Extremely full coverage, known for its ability to cover severe dark circles and blemishes.
- Finish: Matte finish that can feel slightly heavier.
- Best for: Those who need maximum coverage and don’t mind a more substantial texture.
2. Formula and Ingredients
Hourglass Vanish Concealer
- Formulated with clean beauty standards—free from parabens, sulfates, and phthalates.
- Contains skin-nourishing ingredients like squalane and glycerin to hydrate and smooth the skin.
- Suitable for sensitive skin and those who prefer makeup with skincare benefits.
Tarte Shape Tape Concealer
- Contains moisturizing ingredients like shea butter and mango seed butter.
- Known to be long-wearing but can be drying for some, especially around the delicate under-eye area.
- Not labeled as a clean beauty product, which may be a consideration for ingredient-conscious users.
3. Application and Wear
Hourglass Vanish Concealer
- Applies smoothly and blends easily with fingers, brushes, or sponges.
- Lasts around 8-10 hours without significant creasing or fading.
- Lightweight enough for all-day comfort, including on dry or mature skin.
Tarte Shape Tape Concealer
- Offers intense pigmentation but can require careful blending to avoid patchiness.
- Provides all-day wear with minimal touch-ups.
- May crease or settle into fine lines if not set properly, especially on dry skin.
4. Shade Range and Inclusivity
Hourglass Vanish Concealer
- Offers a wide range of shades with warm, cool, and neutral undertones.
- Shade range is comprehensive but slightly smaller compared to Tarte.
Tarte Shape Tape Concealer
- Known for an extensive and inclusive shade range catering to a broad spectrum of skin tones.
- Strong reputation for inclusivity, often praised by users with deeper skin tones.
5. Packaging and Sustainability
Hourglass Vanish Concealer
- Comes in refillable, eco-friendly packaging, emphasizing sustainability.
- Sleek, travel-friendly compact that feels luxurious.
Tarte Shape Tape Concealer
- Packaged in a standard plastic squeeze tube.
- Less emphasis on sustainability compared to Hourglass.
6. Price Point
- Hourglass Vanish Concealer: Positioned in the luxury category, typically priced around $38-$40.
- Tarte Shape Tape Concealer: Mid to high-end price, generally around $27-$30, often available at discounted prices.
Final Verdict: Which One Should You Pick?
| Criteria | Hourglass Vanish Concealer | Tarte Shape Tape Concealer |
|---|---|---|
| Best For | Lightweight, natural matte finish with skincare benefits | Maximum full coverage and long-lasting wear |
| Skin Type | Normal to dry, sensitive | Normal to oily, less ideal for very dry skin |
| Ingredient Preference | Clean beauty, nourishing formula | Moisturizing but not clean beauty |
| Shade Range | Wide but smaller | Very extensive and inclusive |
| Packaging | Refillable, sustainable | Standard plastic tube |
| Price | Higher-end luxury price | More affordable, mid-range |
If you want a concealer that feels like skincare with a natural finish and eco-friendly packaging, Hourglass Vanish is an excellent choice. On the other hand, if you need ultra-full coverage with a wide shade range and don’t mind a heavier texture, Tarte Shape Tape remains a go-to favorite.
Ultimately, your choice depends on your skin type, coverage needs, and values regarding ingredients and sustainability. Both deliver exceptional results, so you really can’t go wrong!