Bold lip colors have become a defining statement in modern makeup, and two brands leading the charge are Jeffree Star Cosmetics and Fenty Beauty. Both brands are celebrated for their daring shades, innovative formulas, and inclusive shade ranges. If you’re torn between which lipstick line to try, this article pits Jeffree Star lipsticks vs. Fenty Beauty to help you decide which bold lip game reigns supreme in 2025.
Brand Overview: Jeffree Star Cosmetics and Fenty Beauty
Jeffree Star Lipsticks
Known for their Velour Liquid Lipsticks, Jeffree Star’s lip products offer vibrant, ultra-matte finishes with intense pigmentation. The brand is beloved for pushing boundaries with unconventional colors like blues, greens, and neon pinks alongside classic reds and nudes.
Fenty Beauty Lipsticks
Fenty Beauty, launched by Rihanna, emphasizes inclusivity and innovation. Their lip products range from matte to satin and gloss finishes, featuring bold shades alongside everyday favorites. The brand combines fashion-forward colors with wearable formulas.
Formula and Texture Comparison
Jeffree Star
- Velour Liquid Lipsticks are known for their long-lasting, waterproof matte finish.
- The formula dries down quickly and feels lightweight but can be drying on some lips.
- Also offers Liquid Frosts, which add shimmer and dimension to lips.
Fenty Beauty
- Offers a variety of lip formulas, including Mattemoiselle Plush Matte, Gloss Bombs, and Slip Shine Sheer Shines.
- Generally more hydrating and comfortable, with options for satin and glossy finishes.
- Matte lipsticks tend to have a softer, less drying formula compared to Jeffree Star.
Shade Range and Boldness
Jeffree Star
- Famous for extreme bold shades like blood reds, blues, purples, and even neon colors.
- Appeals to those who love to stand out with striking, unconventional lip colors.
Fenty Beauty
- Provides a wide range of bold to wearable shades catering to many skin tones.
- Balances adventurous colors with classic reds, berries, and nude options in vibrant finishes.
Longevity and Wear
Jeffree Star
- Known for impressive longevity, with lip colors lasting hours without touch-ups.
- Matte finish resists smudging and fading but may require moisturizing lip prep.
Fenty Beauty
- Long-lasting formulas, especially the matte line, but generally need more frequent reapplication than Jeffree Star.
- Glossy and satin finishes offer hydration but sacrifice some staying power.
Packaging and Aesthetic
- Jeffree Star packaging is bold, flashy, and instantly recognizable with a signature star logo and edgy vibe.
- Fenty Beauty offers sleek, modern packaging with minimalist design focused on accessibility and luxury.
Price Point
- Jeffree Star lipsticks are priced in the mid-to-high range, reflecting luxury branding and niche appeal.
- Fenty Beauty offers competitive pricing with a range of products that cater to various budgets without compromising quality.
Final Verdict: Which Bold Lipstick Wins?
- Choose Jeffree Star Lipsticks if you want ultra-bold, statement-making colors with a long-lasting matte finish and don’t mind a drier texture. Perfect for fearless makeup lovers who want to stand out.
- Choose Fenty Beauty Lipsticks if you prefer a wider variety of formulas, including hydrating mattes and glosses, with bold but wearable shade options suitable for everyday glam and special occasions.
Both brands excel in delivering bold, beautiful lip colors in 2025, so your choice comes down to your preferred finish, comfort, and style. Either way, you’ll be rocking lips that command attention!