When it comes to activewear, leggings are a wardrobe staple for workouts, lounging, and everyday wear. While premium brands often dominate the conversation, Old Navy has emerged as a strong contender in the world of affordable and stylish leggings. But how do Old Navy leggings really compare to other well-known brands in terms of value? Let’s break it down.
Price Comparison: Budget-Friendly vs Premium Investment
Old Navy Leggings generally range from $20 to $40, with frequent sales that bring prices even lower. This makes them one of the most affordable options on the market without compromising too much on quality.
Other Brands, such as Lululemon, Athleta, and Nike, price their leggings from $70 to over $100. These come with advanced fabric technologies, brand prestige, and premium design — but at a cost that may not suit every budget.
Verdict: For those looking to save money while still getting solid performance, Old Navy offers far better affordability.
Fabric and Performance: How Do They Feel?
Old Navy uses a range of proprietary fabrics like PowerSoft, PowerChill, Breathe ON, and Elevate, which are designed to offer comfort, moisture-wicking, and varying levels of compression.
Other brands may use specialized blends such as Lululemon’s Nulu (used in Align leggings) or Athleta’s Powervita, which are known for their buttery softness and second-skin feel.
Verdict: Premium brands may edge ahead in terms of fabric innovation, but Old Navy holds its own impressively for the price, especially with PowerSoft’s comfort and durability.
Style and Variety: Fashion Meets Function
Old Navy consistently updates its legging collections with new colors, prints, lengths, and sizes. Their inclusive range caters to regular, tall, petite, and plus-size shoppers — making the brand widely accessible.
Other brands, while stylish, may have fewer size-inclusive options or limited collections for certain body types.
Verdict: Old Navy wins for inclusive sizing and style variety, making it a versatile option for a diverse range of women.
Durability and Longevity
Premium leggings from brands like Lululemon or Athleta tend to hold up through intense workouts and frequent washing without losing shape. They’re designed for longevity, making them more of an investment piece.
Old Navy leggings, while durable for casual use and light-to-moderate workouts, may show signs of wear (like pilling or stretching) faster under heavy use.
Verdict: If you need leggings that last for years under heavy athletic wear, premium brands might deliver more durability. For casual or moderate use, Old Navy performs well enough.
Comfort and Fit
Old Navy leggings are praised for their comfort, especially with options like PowerSoft that feel smooth and cozy on the skin. They also offer high-rise fits that flatter a range of body types.
Higher-end brands often fine-tune their fit with seamless designs, gussets, and contouring that feel more tailored.
Verdict: Premium leggings may offer a more refined fit, but Old Navy leggings are still highly comfortable and flattering for most body shapes.
Final Verdict: Is Old Navy the Best Value?
Old Navy leggings strike an excellent balance between affordability, comfort, and style. While they might not offer the elite-level performance or luxury feel of premium brands, they deliver tremendous value for everyday wear, light workouts, and fashion-forward comfort.
If you’re on a budget or simply want leggings that look good and feel great without breaking the bank, Old Navy is one of the best value options available today. For athletes or those seeking high-tech fabrics and long-term durability, a splurge on a higher-end brand may be worth it — but for most people, Old Navy leggings offer more than enough to satisfy.
