When it comes to affordable, stylish leggings, both Aeropostale and Old Navy are go-to brands for many shoppers. Each offers a wide range of leggings designed for comfort, everyday wear, and casual style. But if you’re trying to decide between the two, which brand really provides better value? This article breaks down key aspects like comfort, quality, style, and price to help you make an informed choice.
Comfort and Fit: Which Feels Better?
Aeropostale
Aeropostale leggings typically use soft cotton blends combined with spandex for stretch. Customers often praise their high-rise waistbands and flexible fit, which accommodate various body shapes comfortably. They are known for being lightweight and breathable, making them great for casual wear and light activities.
Old Navy
Old Navy leggings tend to offer a slightly wider range of fabric types, including performance blends for activewear and softer cotton-rich blends for everyday comfort. Their leggings often come with a supportive waistband and a four-way stretch, which many users find very comfortable for both lounging and workouts.
Winner: Old Navy slightly edges out Aeropostale on comfort due to their wider fabric variety and inclusion of performance styles.
Quality and Durability: Which Lasts Longer?
Aeropostale
Aeropostale leggings are generally well-made with sturdy stitching, but since they often use thinner cotton blends, some users report issues with pilling and fading after multiple washes. However, their durability is decent for the price point.
Old Navy
Old Navy leggings have a reputation for solid durability, especially their activewear lines. The fabrics tend to maintain their shape and color better after repeated wear and washing. Reinforced seams and quality materials make Old Navy a dependable choice for longer-lasting leggings.
Winner: Old Navy offers better longevity, particularly if you opt for their activewear leggings.
Style and Variety: Which Brand Has More Options?
Aeropostale
Aeropostale focuses on casual and trendy styles with basic colors like black, gray, and navy, alongside seasonal patterns and subtle detailing such as mesh panels or ribbed textures. Their leggings are great for everyday wear and casual outings.
Old Navy
Old Navy provides a broader selection, including everyday leggings, activewear, printed designs, high-waisted options, and even maternity leggings. Their variety caters to different style preferences and needs, from casual wear to fitness.
Winner: Old Navy wins for style variety, offering more choices to fit diverse wardrobes.
Price and Value: Which Brand Gives You More for Your Money?
Aeropostale
Aeropostale leggings are budget-friendly, often priced competitively during sales and promotions. They offer good value if you want comfortable, casual leggings without spending much.
Old Navy
Old Navy leggings are similarly affordable but often have more frequent sales and bulk deals. Their mix of activewear and casual options means you can find leggings suited for both style and performance at a great price.
Winner: Both brands offer excellent value, but Old Navy’s frequent deals and larger range may provide more bang for your buck.
Final Verdict: Aeropostale vs Old Navy Leggings
While both Aeropostale and Old Navy deliver quality leggings at affordable prices, Old Navy stands out as the better overall value. Their superior fabric options, durability, style variety, and performance-focused designs make them a versatile choice for many lifestyles. Aeropostale remains a strong contender for casual, everyday leggings with trendy details but may fall short on durability and variety compared to Old Navy.
If you want leggings mainly for lounging or casual wear and prefer simpler styles, Aeropostale is a solid choice. But for those seeking leggings that can handle active use, longer wear, and a wider range of styles, Old Navy is likely the better investment.
Whether you lean toward Aeropostale or Old Navy, both brands provide comfortable, affordable leggings that can fit seamlessly into your wardrobe. Your final pick should depend on your specific needs for style, comfort, and durability.
