Choosing the perfect foundation can be a game-changer for your makeup routine, and two popular contenders that often come up are Laura Mercier Flawless Fusion Ultra-Longwear Foundation and Tarte Shape Tape Foundation. Both brands promise long-lasting coverage and a flawless finish, but which one truly performs better? In this article, we’ll compare these two foundations side by side to help you decide which might be the better fit for your skin type and makeup needs.
Overview of Laura Mercier Flawless Fusion Ultra-Longwear Foundation
Laura Mercier’s Flawless Fusion foundation is designed to provide a long-lasting, matte finish that controls shine without feeling heavy. It’s known for its:
- Full coverage that’s buildable without caking
- Oil-free, breathable formula
- 15-hour wear time
- Suitable for oily and combination skin types
The foundation is praised for its ability to blur imperfections and provide a natural yet polished look.
Overview of Tarte Shape Tape Foundation
Tarte’s Shape Tape Foundation is a newer launch inspired by their iconic Shape Tape concealer. It offers:
- Full coverage with a natural matte finish
- Buildable and blendable texture
- Long-lasting wear (up to 12 hours)
- Contains skin-loving ingredients like hyaluronic acid and squalane
This foundation aims to provide a flawless finish that also nourishes the skin.
Coverage and Finish
- Laura Mercier Flawless Fusion: Offers a matte finish with medium to full buildable coverage. It excels in controlling oil and shine, making it ideal for oily or combination skin.
- Tarte Shape Tape: Also provides full coverage but leans more towards a natural matte finish with a slightly dewy undertone. It’s hydrating and comfortable on the skin, making it versatile for most skin types.
Winner: If you prefer a strictly matte, shine-free look, Laura Mercier takes the edge. For a natural matte with hydration, Tarte is the pick.
Wear and Longevity
- Laura Mercier: Advertises up to 15 hours of wear with minimal fading and no patchiness, especially effective in humid or oily conditions.
- Tarte: Lasts about 12 hours and holds well throughout the day, with added skin benefits from moisturizing ingredients.
Winner: Laura Mercier has a slight advantage for longer wear, particularly for oily skin or hot climates.
Shade Range and Inclusivity
- Laura Mercier: Offers a solid range of shades, covering many undertones, but some users feel the deeper shades could be expanded.
- Tarte: Known for its extensive shade range and inclusive undertones, Tarte is often praised for catering to a diverse spectrum of skin tones.
Winner: Tarte Shape Tape wins in shade inclusivity and diversity.
Texture and Application
- Laura Mercier: Has a medium-thick texture that blends well with brushes or sponges but can feel a bit heavy if over-applied.
- Tarte: Lightweight and creamy, it applies smoothly and blends easily without streaking.
Winner: Tarte’s texture is generally preferred for ease of application.
Skin Type Compatibility
- Laura Mercier: Best suited for oily and combination skin due to its matte finish and oil-control properties.
- Tarte: Versatile enough for dry, normal, combination, and oily skin thanks to hydrating ingredients.
Winner: Tarte is more universally compatible across skin types.
Price and Value
- Laura Mercier: Generally priced around $48–$50 per bottle.
- Tarte: Slightly more affordable, typically around $38–$42.
Winner: Tarte offers better value without compromising quality.
Final Verdict: Which Performs Better?
Both foundations excel in their own right. Choose Laura Mercier Flawless Fusion if you want a long-lasting, matte foundation specifically designed to combat oil and shine—ideal for oily or combination skin types needing extended wear. Opt for Tarte Shape Tape Foundation if you prefer a hydrating, comfortable formula with full coverage, a natural finish, and a wide shade range that suits all skin types.
Ultimately, your choice depends on your skin’s needs and your preferred finish. Both foundations are top-tier options in 2025’s makeup landscape.
Quick Tips for Best Results
- Pair Laura Mercier with a mattifying primer for enhanced oil control.
- Use a hydrating primer under Tarte Shape Tape for extra glow and smooth application.
- Always set your foundation with a suitable powder or setting spray for longevity.
Whether you prioritize shine control, hydration, or shade inclusivity, both foundations have something exceptional to offer!