NYX Butter Gloss is a beloved lip gloss known for its creamy texture, hydrating feel, and beautiful shine—all at an affordable price. But if you’re looking to switch things up or explore other options that deliver a similarly smooth and glossy finish, you’re in the right place. This article covers the best alternatives to NYX Butter Gloss that offer luscious shine and comfortable wear.
1. Fenty Beauty Gloss Bomb Universal Lip Luminizer
- Why It’s Great: Fenty Gloss Bomb is a cult favorite thanks to its ultra-hydrating formula enriched with shea butter, which plumps lips while delivering a stunning glass-like shine.
- Finish: High-shine with a slightly thicker, luxurious texture.
- Shade Range: Limited but universally flattering shades designed to suit all skin tones.
2. Maybelline Lifter Gloss
- Why It’s Great: This gloss features hyaluronic acid for hydration and provides a beautiful shine without stickiness. It’s a great drugstore alternative with nourishing benefits.
- Finish: Glossy with a smooth, cushiony feel.
- Shade Range: Offers a variety of shades from clear to soft pinks and berries.
3. Milani Keep It Full Nourishing Lip Plumper
- Why It’s Great: Combining gloss and plumping effects, Milani’s lip gloss hydrates while giving lips a fuller appearance, similar to NYX Butter Gloss’s smooth texture but with added volume.
- Finish: Glossy with a subtle plumping tingle.
- Shade Range: Vibrant range of shades including nudes, pinks, and reds.
4. Burt’s Bees Lip Shine
- Why It’s Great: Made with natural ingredients like moringa oil and shea butter, Burt’s Bees Lip Shine offers a more natural, nourishing gloss experience that’s smooth and shiny.
- Finish: Sheer with a soft shine and moisturizing feel.
- Shade Range: More limited but includes several flattering neutral shades.
5. Revlon Super Lustrous Lip Gloss
- Why It’s Great: Revlon’s gloss is rich in color and shine, offering a creamy, non-sticky texture that feels comfortable for long wear. It’s a reliable drugstore option with great pigmentation.
- Finish: High-shine and creamy.
- Shade Range: Wide variety of colors from subtle to bold.
6. e.l.f. Cosmetics Lip Lacquer
- Why It’s Great: Affordable and effective, e.l.f. Lip Lacquer delivers a glossy finish with a lightweight feel similar to NYX Butter Gloss. It’s perfect for those who want shine without heaviness.
- Finish: Glossy and smooth.
- Shade Range: Multiple shades including nudes, pinks, and reds.
7. L’Oréal Paris Colour Riche La Lacque Gloss
- Why It’s Great: This gloss combines intense shine with rich color payoff and hydration, providing a luxurious feel similar to NYX Butter Gloss.
- Finish: Glossy with vibrant pigmentation.
- Shade Range: Extensive with trendy shades.
How to Choose the Best NYX Butter Gloss Alternative
- Consider Your Budget: Some alternatives like Fenty Gloss Bomb are higher-end, while others like Maybelline or e.l.f. are more affordable.
- Think About Finish Preferences: Do you want a sheer gloss, plumping effect, or rich pigmentation?
- Check Ingredients: If hydration is key, look for glosses with nourishing oils or hyaluronic acid.
- Shade Range: Choose a brand offering shades that complement your skin tone and personal style.
Final Thoughts
While NYX Butter Gloss is a standout favorite, plenty of other lip glosses offer that perfect blend of smooth texture, shine, and hydration. Whether you want to splurge on a luxury formula or stick to budget-friendly finds, these alternatives provide fantastic options to keep your lips looking glossy and gorgeous all day long. Try a few to find your new favorite shine!