When shopping for a mascara that delivers dramatic lashes and lasting wear, Benefit Cosmetics offers several top-tier options. But one big question often arises: should you choose waterproof or regular mascara? Each formula has unique benefits depending on your needs, lifestyle, and lash goals. In this article, we’ll break down the pros and cons of both to help you decide which Benefit mascara is right for you.
Understanding the Difference: Formula and Performance
Regular Benefit mascaras (like They’re Real! and Roller Lash) use water-based or lightweight wax formulas that focus on volume, curl, and easy removal.
Waterproof versions, on the other hand, are designed to withstand moisture, sweat, and humidity using oil-based and water-resistant components.
Waterproof Benefit Mascara: Pros and Cons
✅ Pros
- Long-lasting wear: Ideal for long days, weddings, workouts, or hot climates.
- Smudge-proof: Won’t flake or smear, even if your eyes water.
- Sweat & humidity resistant: Great for summer, oily lids, or emotional events.
❌ Cons
- Harder to remove: Requires oil-based makeup remover or micellar water.
- Can dry out lashes: Frequent use may cause brittleness or lash fallout.
- Less buildable: Often less flexible for layering compared to regular versions.
Top Pick: Benefit BADgal BANG! Waterproof – delivers intense volume with waterproof wear, perfect for dramatic eye looks that need to stay put.
Regular Benefit Mascara: Pros and Cons
✅ Pros
- Easier to apply and remove: Comes off with regular cleanser or makeup wipes.
- Gentler on lashes: Less drying, better for daily use or sensitive eyes.
- More flexible formula: Great for building volume or layering without stiffness.
❌ Cons
- Less resistance to moisture: May smudge with tears, sweat, or rain.
- Shorter wear time: Might not hold up for 12+ hours or active situations.
Top Pick: Benefit Roller Lash – a fan-favorite for curling and lifting lashes with a lightweight, long-wearing formula that’s easy on the eyes.
When to Choose Waterproof Benefit Mascara
- You’re attending an event where you might cry or sweat
- You live in a humid climate
- You need all-day wear without touch-ups
- You’re going swimming or working out
- You have oily lids and your mascara often transfers
When to Choose Regular Benefit Mascara
- You wear mascara daily and want something gentle
- You prefer quick and easy removal
- Your eyes are sensitive or prone to irritation
- You don’t need waterproof protection
- You enjoy changing up your look or reapplying
Expert Tip: Try a Mascara Primer
If you love the feel of regular mascara but need better staying power, consider using Benefit’s They’re Real! Tinted Primer. It boosts wear time, enhances curl, and helps your mascara resist smudging—without needing a waterproof formula.
Final Verdict: Which Is Right for You?
Choose waterproof if long-lasting, smudge-resistant wear is your priority and you’re okay with the extra effort in removal.
Stick with regular if you value comfort, ease of removal, and flexible wear for everyday use.
Ultimately, both types have their place in a beauty routine—and many Benefit lovers keep one of each on hand for different occasions. Whether you’re braving the elements or just running errands, there’s a perfect Benefit mascara to match your lash needs.