Benefit Cosmetics is known for its iconic mascaras like They’re Real!, Roller Lash, and Badgal Bang!. While these mascaras deliver impressive results, their price tags can be a bit steep for budget-conscious beauty lovers. The good news? There are several drugstore mascaras that deliver similar volume, length, and curl—without the high-end cost. Below, we’ve rounded up the best affordable alternatives to Benefit mascaras that give your lashes a stunning boost.
1. L’Oréal Voluminous Lash Paradise
Alternative to: Benefit They’re Real! Mascara
This mascara has earned a cult following of its own—and for good reason. With a fluffy hourglass brush and richly pigmented formula, Lash Paradise delivers incredible length and volume, much like They’re Real!. It separates lashes beautifully, lasts all day, and doesn’t clump. Plus, it’s often under $12.
Why It’s a Great Dupe:
- Intense length and fluttery finish
- Doesn’t smudge or flake
- Dramatic false-lash effect on a budget
2. Maybelline Lash Sensational Mascara
Alternative to: Benefit Roller Lash
If you love the curling and lifting effect of Roller Lash, Maybelline’s Lash Sensational is a top-tier dupe. The curved silicone brush hugs each lash, creating a fanned-out, lifted appearance that mimics the look of a lash curler. It’s perfect for naturally straight lashes.
Why It’s a Great Dupe:
- Curl-enhancing wand design
- Adds definition and separation
- Long-lasting formula that stays put
3. Essence Lash Princess False Lash Effect Mascara
Alternative to: Benefit Badgal Bang!
Badgal Bang! is known for its intense volume and jet-black finish. For a fraction of the price, Lash Princess delivers bold volume and length that rivals high-end mascaras. It’s one of the most praised drugstore mascaras and regularly tops beauty editor lists.
Why It’s a Great Dupe:
- Serious volume with one coat
- Deep black pigment for dramatic lashes
- Cruelty-free and under $6
4. Covergirl Exhibitionist Mascara
Alternative to: Benefit They’re Real! Magnet Mascara
The They’re Real! Magnet Mascara promises extra lift and extreme length thanks to a magnetic brush and formula. Covergirl’s Exhibitionist Mascara offers similar lift and dramatic lash definition, with a creamy texture that builds easily.
Why It’s a Great Dupe:
- Bold, eye-opening effect
- Buildable length and volume
- Smudge-proof and ophthalmologist-tested
5. e.l.f. Big Mood Mascara
Alternative to: Benefit Mascaras in General
For those looking for an affordable mascara that combines volume, lift, and definition all in one, Big Mood is a solid choice. With a large hourglass brush and lightweight formula, it gives Benefit-level lashes without the luxury price.
Why It’s a Great Dupe:
- Vegan and cruelty-free
- Dramatic results for under $10
- Easy to apply and layer
Final Thoughts: Save Money, Keep the Drama
You don’t need to spend big to get big results. Whether you love the lift of Roller Lash or the volume of Badgal Bang!, there’s an affordable dupe that delivers. These budget-friendly mascaras prove that stunning lashes don’t have to come with a luxury price tag. With the right formula and brush, your lashes can look Benefit-beautiful—without the Benefit price.