When it comes to affordable, casual fashion, Gap and Old Navy are two brands that dominate the scene—especially when you’re looking for cozy, stylish sweatshirts. Both brands are owned by the same parent company (Gap Inc.), but they cater to slightly different audiences in terms of price, quality, and design. So, when shopping for your next go-to pullover or hoodie, the question is: Which is better for women—Gap sweatshirts or Old Navy sweatshirts?
Let’s break it down across key categories: fabric, fit, style options, pricing, and overall value.
Fabric and Quality: Which One Feels Better?
Gap Sweatshirts
- Typically made with higher-grade cotton blends
- Many feature brushed fleece interiors, organic cotton, or “Vintage Soft” fabric
- More structured and heavier-weight material
- Feels luxurious, lasts through many washes
Old Navy Sweatshirts
- Lighter in weight, with more polyester blends
- Some newer options feature PowerSoft fleece or CozySherpa
- Often softer out of the package, but may show wear more quickly over time
Winner: Gap, for its long-lasting construction and premium textures
Fit and Comfort: Relaxed or Fitted?
Gap Sweatshirts
- More tailored and structured fits, though relaxed options are available
- Sizing skews slightly more fashion-forward with boxy cuts or cropped designs
- Feels more elevated and put-together even when casual
Old Navy Sweatshirts
- Known for relaxed, comfy fits across the board
- Offers extended sizing, including Petite, Tall, and Plus
- Great for loungewear or layering without feeling stiff
Winner: Tie
Gap wins for refined fit and style; Old Navy wins for size inclusivity and relaxed comfort
Style and Design Variety
Gap
- Offers a more minimalist, timeless look
- Features subtle logos, neutral tones, and modern silhouettes
- Limited seasonal prints, but elevated basics are the focus
Old Navy
- Embraces seasonal trends and color variety
- Includes bold graphics, slogans, prints, and themed designs (e.g., holiday collections)
- More playful and casual in aesthetic
Winner: Depends on your style
Go with Gap for clean, classic looks—choose Old Navy if you like to play with prints and fun designs.
Price and Affordability
Gap
- Sweatshirts range from $49–$89 regularly
- Often runs promotions and site-wide sales (up to 40–50% off)
- Higher price point, but reflects the fabric quality
Old Navy
- Sweatshirts typically cost $20–$40
- Frequent markdowns, rewards, and seasonal clearance sales
- Great for bulk-buying or refreshing your wardrobe on a budget
Winner: Old Navy, for unbeatable pricing and frequent sales
Longevity and Wear Over Time
Gap sweatshirts tend to:
- Maintain their shape and color through frequent washing
- Feel more structured, even after months of use
Old Navy sweatshirts tend to:
- Soften quickly but may lose shape or pill over time
- Require more delicate care for long-term wear
Winner: Gap, for long-term durability
Best Picks from Each Brand
Top Gap Sweatshirts for Women:
- Vintage Soft Crewneck
- Embroidered Logo Hoodie
- Organic Cotton Cropped Sweatshirt
Top Old Navy Sweatshirts for Women:
- Breathe ON Pullover Hoodie
- Cozy Sherpa Half-Zip
- Oversized Graphic Sweatshirts
Final Verdict: Which Brand Is Right for You?
Choose Gap if:
- You want elevated basics with a premium feel
- You’re willing to invest a bit more for long-term wear
- You prefer minimalist, timeless styles
Choose Old Navy if:
- You’re shopping on a budget
- You want fun colors, graphics, and seasonal variety
- You prioritize relaxed fits and size inclusivity
Bottom Line
Both Gap and Old Navy sweatshirts have their strengths—Gap delivers long-lasting luxury, while Old Navy offers unbeatable value and variety. The best choice depends on your lifestyle, fashion priorities, and budget. For many women, mixing both brands into a wardrobe is the smartest move.