Sustainable footwear has become a major trend as more consumers prioritize eco-friendly and ethical products. Two brands that stand out in this space are Rothy’s and Allbirds. Both have built strong reputations for combining style, comfort, and sustainability. But if you’re deciding between the two, which brand truly comes out on top? In this article, we’ll compare Rothy’s and Allbirds across key factors like materials, comfort, style, price, and environmental impact to help you make an informed choice.
Sustainability: Materials and Environmental Impact
Rothy’s is best known for their innovative use of recycled plastic water bottles to create soft, breathable knit uppers. Their shoes are also fully recyclable, meaning worn-out pairs can be returned to the company to be remade into new products. This closed-loop system significantly reduces waste.
Allbirds, on the other hand, uses natural and renewable materials such as merino wool, eucalyptus tree fiber, and sugarcane-based foam soles. Their carbon footprint is minimized through sustainable sourcing and carbon offset initiatives.
Winner: Both brands excel in sustainability but with different approaches—Rothy’s focuses on recycled plastics and circularity, while Allbirds emphasizes natural fibers and carbon neutrality. It’s a tie, depending on your sustainability values.
Comfort and Fit
Comfort is a top priority for customers of both brands.
Rothy’s shoes are praised for their flexibility, breathable knit fabric, and cushioned insoles. They mold well to the foot, offering a sock-like fit that works well for casual and workwear styles.
Allbirds’ shoes are renowned for their soft merino wool uppers and cushy, shock-absorbing soles, making them excellent for active wear and all-day comfort.
Winner: It depends on use—Rothy’s shine in casual to semi-formal wear with a snug fit, while Allbirds offer superior comfort for athletic or outdoor activities.
Style and Variety
Rothy’s is often favored for its sleek, feminine designs, especially their flats, loafers, and sneakers that transition easily from office to weekend. They also offer styles like boots and sandals, catering mostly to women but expanding into men’s collections.
Allbirds offers a more unisex, sporty aesthetic with a focus on casual sneakers and running shoes. Their designs are minimalist and versatile but tend to lean toward casual and athleisure wear.
Winner: Rothy’s takes the edge for style diversity and polished options, while Allbirds is perfect for those who prioritize casual and sporty looks.
Price and Value
Rothy’s shoes generally retail between $125 and $165, while Allbirds shoes typically range from $95 to $145. Both brands offer high-quality, durable shoes with sustainable credentials, but Allbirds tends to have a slightly more affordable price point.
Winner: Allbirds offers better value for those seeking sustainability on a budget, but Rothy’s justifies its price with a focus on refined style and versatility.
Durability and Maintenance
Rothy’s shoes are machine washable, which is a big plus for easy care. Their sturdy construction holds up well with regular use, although knit uppers may snag if handled roughly.
Allbirds shoes require hand washing and gentle care to preserve their natural materials. They are durable but may not withstand harsh environments or heavy wear as well as Rothy’s.
Winner: Rothy’s leads in ease of maintenance and durability for everyday wear.
Final Verdict: Which Brand Wins?
Both Rothy’s and Allbirds deliver impressive sustainable footwear options, but your choice depends on your priorities:
- Choose Rothy’s if you want polished, versatile shoes with easy maintenance and recycled-material innovation.
- Choose Allbirds if you prefer natural materials, lower price points, and sporty, casual comfort with a focus on carbon neutrality.
Ultimately, both brands are winners in the sustainable shoe space, each excelling in different areas to serve diverse lifestyles and tastes.
