As sustainability becomes a key factor in fashion choices, brands like Allbirds and Rothy’s are leading the charge with eco-friendly, stylish, and comfortable shoes. But how do they compare—and which one is right for you? In this article, we break down the differences between Allbirds and Rothy’s in terms of materials, comfort, style, durability, price, and sustainability practices.
Brand Overview
Allbirds
Founded in 2016, Allbirds is known for its minimalist design, exceptional comfort, and innovative use of natural materials like merino wool, eucalyptus tree fiber, and sugarcane-based soles. The brand began with sneakers and has since expanded to include running shoes, flats, and clothing.
Rothy’s
Rothy’s launched in 2012 with a mission to turn recycled plastic into fashion-forward, everyday footwear. Best known for their ballet flats, loafers, and pointed shoes, Rothy’s combines sustainability with chic, urban style. Their shoes are made from recycled water bottles and come in a wide variety of colors and patterns.
Materials and Sustainability
Allbirds Materials
- Merino wool (Wool Runners)
- Eucalyptus tree fiber (Tree Runners)
- Sugarcane EVA soles
- Castor bean oil insoles
Allbirds is a certified B Corporation and strives for carbon neutrality. They publish their carbon footprint per product and offset emissions through renewable energy and carbon capture projects.
Rothy’s Materials
- Recycled plastic water bottles (knit uppers)
- Bio-based outsoles
- Recycled rubber and marine plastic in some products
Rothy’s shoes are fully machine washable and 100% recyclable through their recycling program. They also operate a factory in China that runs on responsible labor and sustainability standards.
Winner (Sustainability): Tie – Both brands are deeply committed to sustainability, but Allbirds is slightly more transparent about carbon offsets.
Comfort and Fit
Allbirds Comfort
Allbirds are widely praised for their soft, cushiony feel—especially the Wool Runners, which feel like cozy slippers. The Tree models are lighter and more breathable, great for warmer weather.
Rothy’s Comfort
Rothy’s shoes are flexible and form-fitting, with a slightly snug fit due to the knit upper. While they don’t have much arch support, many users find them extremely comfortable for walking and standing.
Winner (Comfort): Allbirds – especially if you prioritize arch support and plush footbeds.
Style and Versatility
Allbirds Style
Allbirds leans toward sporty and casual aesthetics. Their designs are minimal and functional, great for everyday wear, travel, and athleisure looks.
Rothy’s Style
Rothy’s offers more polished and professional silhouettes, including ballet flats, pointed-toe shoes, loafers, and even handbags. They’re perfect for workwear, events, and smart-casual outfits.
Winner (Style): Rothy’s – ideal for dressier or office-appropriate options.
Durability and Care
Allbirds Durability
Allbirds shoes are durable for everyday wear but may show signs of wear in harsher conditions. Wool models are less ideal for rain and wet environments. Most are machine washable, but should always be air dried.
Rothy’s Durability
Rothy’s shoes are known for holding up well even with frequent use. Their tightly knit upper resists stretching and fading, and every pair is machine washable, maintaining shape wash after wash.
Winner (Durability): Rothy’s – especially for urban wear and repeated cleaning.
Price Comparison
- Allbirds: Prices range from $98 to $145 for most shoes.
- Rothy’s: Flats and loafers typically range from $129 to $179.
Rothy’s shoes are generally more expensive, but their wide selection of styles and versatility might justify the higher cost for some.
Winner (Affordability): Allbirds – better value for casual and athletic shoes.
Final Verdict: Which Brand Is Best for You?
Choose Allbirds if you want:
- Maximum comfort and softness
- A sporty or casual look
- More affordable pricing
- A carbon-conscious brand with natural materials
Choose Rothy’s if you want:
- Stylish flats, loafers, or work-friendly options
- Highly durable and machine-washable shoes
- Versatile designs for both casual and professional outfits
- A brand focused on recycled plastic and long-term wear
Conclusion
Both Allbirds and Rothy’s are standout sustainable brands, offering unique benefits depending on your lifestyle. If you lean toward comfort, softness, and sport-inspired design, Allbirds is a great fit. If you need stylish, washable shoes for everyday elegance or workwear, Rothy’s is the way to go. Whichever you choose, you’ll be stepping into a more sustainable future.
