The Brooks Ghost 14 has long been a favorite among neutral runners, known for its plush cushioning and smooth ride. But in a market saturated with high-performing running shoes, how does it stack up against other fan-favorites like the Nike Pegasus 40, ASICS Gel-Cumulus 25, New Balance 880v13, and HOKA Clifton 9? In this comparison, we’ll break down how the Brooks Ghost 14 performs against top competitors across comfort, durability, fit, weight, and overall value.
1. Comfort and Cushioning
Brooks Ghost 14
- Full-length DNA Loft cushioning offers a soft, consistent feel
- Excellent shock absorption for long runs
- Smooth transitions and responsive ride
Nike Pegasus 40
- React foam midsole is firmer and springier
- More responsive for speed workouts
- Slightly less forgiving on longer runs
ASICS Gel-Cumulus 25
- Combines FF BLAST™ cushioning with GEL® for a plush feel
- Feels slightly softer than Ghost 14 but heavier
- Great for runners who want extra underfoot padding
New Balance 880v13
- Balanced Fresh Foam X cushioning
- Slightly firmer than Ghost 14, offering a snappier ride
- Ideal for runners who prefer structure over softness
HOKA Clifton 9
- Maximalist foam stack with a super-plush feel
- Lighter than Ghost 14 but less traditional ride
- Great for recovery runs but less versatile
Winner: Tie between Ghost 14 and ASICS Cumulus 25 for cushioned daily runs.
2. Fit and Upper Design
Brooks Ghost 14
- Engineered mesh upper with 3D Fit Print offers a secure, adaptive fit
- Accommodates wide feet well with multiple width options
- Breathable and padded in all the right places
Nike Pegasus 40
- Sleeker upper but can run narrow
- More performance-oriented fit
- Better suited for narrow or low-volume feet
ASICS Gel-Cumulus 25
- Soft upper with plush tongue and collar
- Slightly heavier upper construction
- Good lockdown but bulkier overall
New Balance 880v13
- Streamlined fit with premium materials
- Comfortable for daily wear and long distances
- Available in wide sizing
HOKA Clifton 9
- Roomy forefoot but snug midfoot
- Lightweight and breathable
- May feel unstable for runners needing more support
Winner: Brooks Ghost 14 for fit versatility and comfort across foot shapes.
3. Weight and Responsiveness
Brooks Ghost 14
- Weight: ~9.9 oz (Men’s) / ~8.8 oz (Women’s)
- Medium responsiveness, prioritizes comfort over speed
Nike Pegasus 40
- Lighter and snappier ride
- Excellent for tempo runs or workouts
ASICS Gel-Cumulus 25
- Heavier and softer; less responsive
- Better suited for easy or recovery runs
New Balance 880v13
- Slightly lighter than Ghost 14
- Offers better energy return with firmer cushioning
HOKA Clifton 9
- Lighter than Ghost despite more cushion
- Smooth, rolling ride but not as fast off the toe
Winner: Nike Pegasus 40 for responsiveness and weight.
4. Durability and Longevity
Brooks Ghost 14
- High-abrasion rubber outsole ensures solid lifespan (~400+ miles)
- Durable upper that resists stretching
Nike Pegasus 40
- Solid durability but React foam may compress over time
- Outsole wears faster in high-mileage conditions
ASICS Gel-Cumulus 25
- Durable outsole and premium midsole hold up well
- Good for high-mileage runners
New Balance 880v13
- Excellent build quality and outsole grip
- Holds up well over long distances
HOKA Clifton 9
- Midsole foam wears quicker with daily use
- Less rubber coverage on outsole
Winner: Brooks Ghost 14 and New Balance 880v13 for overall durability.
5. Price and Value
Brooks Ghost 14
- MSRP: Around $140
- High value for comfort and durability
Nike Pegasus 40
- MSRP: Around $130
- Good value for performance versatility
ASICS Gel-Cumulus 25
- MSRP: Around $140
- Justified by the soft, plush experience
New Balance 880v13
- MSRP: Around $140
- Excellent for runners who want a more structured neutral shoe
HOKA Clifton 9
- MSRP: Around $145
- Slightly pricier but niche appeal for maximalist runners
Winner: Nike Pegasus 40 for versatility at a slightly lower cost.
Conclusion: Which Shoe Wins?
If your priority is comfort, durability, and all-day wearability, the Brooks Ghost 14 remains a top-tier choice. It offers a smooth, cushioned ride that accommodates a wide range of runners. However, if you’re after speed and responsiveness, the Nike Pegasus 40 may suit you better. For runners who want maximum softness, the ASICS Gel-Cumulus 25 and HOKA Clifton 9 are great alternatives, while the New Balance 880v13 wins points for its all-around balance.
Overall Winner: Brooks Ghost 14
Thanks to its wide appeal, comfort, and durability, the Ghost 14 continues to hold its ground as a best-in-class daily trainer.
