“Dad shoes” have gone from suburban staple to streetwear essential, and two models stand out at the top of the category: the Nike Vomero 5 and the New Balance 990. Both sneakers boast a retro running aesthetic, premium comfort, and plenty of sneakerhead love. But which one deserves a spot in your rotation? Let’s break down the details to determine the ultimate dad shoe winner.
Design & Aesthetic: Sleek vs Chunky
Nike Vomero 5
The Vomero 5 leans into a more futuristic and layered design. With mesh underlays, TPU cage overlays, and reflective accents, it feels technical yet stylish. It’s sleek for a dad shoe, which helps it work well in both sporty and fashion-forward outfits.
New Balance 990
The 990, especially in its v5 and v6 forms, stays true to New Balance’s heritage—chunky, sturdy, and unmistakably retro. Its suede and mesh combo give it that classic “Made in the USA” feel that’s clean and timeless. If you’re after a bulkier silhouette, the 990 wins here.
Winner: Tie – depends on your personal style. Vomero 5 for techwear vibes, 990 for heritage appeal.
Comfort and Cushioning: Zoom vs ENCAP
Nike Vomero 5
Designed originally as a performance runner, the Vomero 5 features Nike’s Cushlon and Zoom Air cushioning for a responsive ride. It’s lightweight, breathable, and excels for all-day wear.
New Balance 990
The 990 uses ENCAP midsole technology, which combines soft EVA cushioning with a firm polyurethane rim. While slightly heavier, the 990 offers solid arch support and a cushy underfoot feel, perfect for walking or standing all day.
Winner: New Balance 990 – it’s hard to beat the plush, orthopedic-level comfort.
Sizing and Fit: True to Size vs Wide-Friendly
Nike Vomero 5
Generally runs true to size, with a snug fit that hugs the foot well. However, wide-footed wearers may find it slightly narrow due to the sleek shape.
New Balance 990
Known for offering wide sizes, the 990 is a go-to for those with broader feet. The fit is roomy and supportive, making it one of the most inclusive dad shoes on the market.
Winner: New Balance 990 – especially for those needing wide or custom fits.
Versatility: Style Meets Function
Nike Vomero 5
Pairs beautifully with joggers, cargo pants, or even tailored trousers. Its balance of techwear and streetwear gives it a modern edge that resonates with younger fashion crowds.
New Balance 990
The 990 is the king of normcore. Rock it with jeans, sweats, or shorts—it rarely looks out of place. While not as “trendy,” it has a timelessness that makes it a wardrobe mainstay.
Winner: Nike Vomero 5 for trendiness, 990 for timeless versatility.
Price & Availability
Nike Vomero 5
Usually retails around $160–$180, but popular colorways often resell for more. Limited drops can make it hard to find at retail.
New Balance 990
Retail prices are higher, often starting at $200–$220 due to the “Made in USA” label. However, restocks are more common, and quality is consistently excellent.
Winner: Nike Vomero 5 for affordability, 990 for build quality.
Final Verdict: Which Dad Shoe Wins?
| Category | Winner |
|---|---|
| Design | Tie |
| Comfort | New Balance 990 |
| Fit & Sizing | New Balance 990 |
| Style Versatility | Nike Vomero 5 |
| Price vs Quality | Tie |
Overall Winner: New Balance 990 (by a slight edge)
If you want all-day comfort, premium materials, and that unmistakable “dad energy,” the New Balance 990 is your best bet. However, if you’re leaning into fashion-forward streetwear with a performance edge, the Nike Vomero 5 brings more modern flair. In the end, both are icons—pick based on your personal priorities.
