Shearling Jackets vs. Faux Fur Jackets: Which Is Right for You?

When it comes to winter outerwear, few styles offer the same level of warmth, comfort, and chicness as shearling and faux fur jackets. Both are timeless, luxurious options that elevate any cold-weather wardrobe, but choosing between the two can be tricky. Each offers unique benefits, depending on your preferences for warmth, texture, ethical considerations, and style.

In this article, we’ll explore the differences between shearling and faux fur jackets to help you decide which is the better choice for you.

1. Material: Natural vs. Synthetic

Shearling Jackets
Shearling jackets are made from sheepskin or lambskin, where the wool is left intact on one side of the hide. The wool provides natural insulation, keeping you incredibly warm while the leather side offers durability and a sleek finish. Authentic shearling is known for being soft, breathable, and extremely insulating. It’s ideal for very cold temperatures due to its ability to trap body heat while remaining lightweight.

Pros: Superior warmth, breathability, and natural durability. The material is also long-lasting when cared for properly.
Cons: More expensive due to the use of animal products and the labor-intensive tanning process.

Faux Fur Jackets
Faux fur jackets, on the other hand, are made from synthetic fibers designed to mimic the look and feel of real fur. These jackets are usually crafted from polyester, acrylic, or modacrylic fibers that are dyed and shaped to resemble animal fur. Modern faux fur can be incredibly soft and luxurious, offering a similar look to real fur without the ethical concerns.

Pros: More affordable, animal-friendly, and comes in a variety of colors and styles. Faux fur can be lighter and more versatile than shearling.
Cons: While warm, faux fur does not offer the same level of insulation as shearling and may not perform as well in extremely cold weather.

2. Warmth and Insulation

Shearling Jackets
Shearling jackets excel when it comes to warmth. The natural wool fibers provide exceptional insulation, trapping air and regulating body temperature even in freezing temperatures. Since shearling is a natural material, it also has moisture-wicking properties, which can help keep you dry and comfortable when the weather is particularly wet or snowy.

Ideal For: Extremely cold climates or long periods of exposure to the outdoors.
Style Tip: Look for shearling-lined bomber jackets, aviators, or long coats for maximum warmth without sacrificing style.

Faux Fur Jackets
Faux fur jackets can be warm, but they don’t offer the same level of insulation as shearling. While they provide a luxurious look and feel, they’re more suitable for moderate cold, such as chilly autumn days or milder winters. However, high-quality faux fur can still keep you cozy in slightly colder temperatures.

Ideal For: Mild winters, chilly evenings, or fashion-focused outerwear that doesn’t require the ultimate warmth.
Style Tip: Opt for faux fur styles with thick pile or a plush finish for extra warmth, and consider layering them with additional sweaters or scarves.

3. Style and Aesthetics

Shearling Jackets
Shearling jackets tend to have a more rugged, classic appeal. They often come in earthy tones like browns, tans, and creams, giving them a vintage, timeless aesthetic. Shearling jackets pair perfectly with both casual and more polished looks. Whether you’re going for an edgy aviator style or a classic, tailored coat, shearling adds a cozy yet refined feel to any outfit.

Style Tip: Pair a shearling jacket with denim, leather pants, or skirts for a stylish, balanced outfit. For a chic winter look, go for a long shearling coat over a fitted dress.

Faux Fur Jackets
Faux fur jackets are synonymous with glamour and luxury. They often come in a wide range of colors and textures, from soft pastels to bold, statement hues. Faux fur jackets lend themselves to more playful, fashion-forward looks and are often seen as a statement piece. Whether you prefer long, shaggy fur or sleek, short cuts, faux fur can add a touch of drama to any outfit.

Style Tip: Faux fur is perfect for evening events, stylish brunches, or casual outings. Wear a long faux fur coat over a little black dress, or pair it with trousers for a trendy look.

4. Ethical Considerations

Shearling Jackets
Since shearling comes from real sheepskin or lambskin, it’s not considered cruelty-free. This has led to growing concerns over the ethical implications of wearing real fur and shearling. If you’re an animal lover or someone who prioritizes ethical fashion, it’s important to know where the shearling jacket comes from. Some brands source their shearling from farms with higher welfare standards, so be sure to do your research.

Considerations: If you’re concerned about animal welfare, look for brands that offer sustainable or ethically sourced shearling options, or consider investing in second-hand shearling to reduce environmental impact.

Faux Fur Jackets
Faux fur jackets are a more ethical option as they are entirely synthetic and don’t involve any animal products. This makes them the go-to choice for people who are vegan, eco-conscious, or just prefer to avoid supporting industries that rely on animal-derived materials.

Considerations: Though faux fur is cruelty-free, it’s still important to keep in mind that synthetic materials are often made from plastics and petroleum-based fibers, which can have environmental implications. Look for faux fur jackets made from recycled or sustainable materials if you want to minimize your environmental footprint.

5. Maintenance and Durability

Shearling Jackets
Shearling jackets are incredibly durable, with proper care. They can last for many years, becoming softer and more comfortable over time. However, shearling requires special care when cleaning and storing. It’s important to have them professionally cleaned or spot cleaned to avoid damage. Shearling is also susceptible to water damage, so it’s crucial to treat it with a waterproofing spray.

Care Tips: Keep your shearling jacket stored in a cool, dry place. Avoid getting it wet, and clean it with gentle leather cleaners or take it to a professional for maintenance.

Faux Fur Jackets
Faux fur jackets are easier to maintain compared to shearling. Most faux fur jackets are machine washable, though it’s always best to check the label first. They tend to retain their shape and color for a long time but may shed or mat over time, particularly with regular wear. Be sure to store faux fur jackets in a way that prevents crushing or tangling.

Care Tips: Gently brush faux fur after wear to keep it looking plush. Wash faux fur jackets according to the care instructions, usually in cold water on a delicate cycle, and air dry.

Conclusion: Which One Is Right for You?

Both shearling and faux fur jackets have their own unique appeal and benefits, so the choice ultimately depends on your personal preferences, lifestyle, and values.

Choose Shearling if you need a jacket that offers exceptional warmth, durability, and timeless style. Shearling is ideal for colder climates and those who prefer natural materials.
Choose Faux Fur if you’re looking for a stylish, animal-friendly, and more affordable option that still offers a glamorous, high-fashion look. Faux fur is perfect for fashion lovers who want variety and easy maintenance.

No matter which option you choose, both shearling and faux fur jackets can add a chic, cozy element to your wardrobe. Consider your specific needs, and you’ll be ready to embrace winter in style!